Divoom team discussing product support

How to Redesign a Red-and-Green Pixel Status Icon So It Works in Grayscale

Written by Divoom Professional Team

Updated on

Give each state a different shape before you change any colors. For example, put a check mark inside a circle for ready and an exclamation mark inside a triangle for attention. Keep the green and red if they fit the design, then preview both icons in grayscale at the final pixel size. The states should remain distinguishable when the colors are gone.

Do the check on a duplicate or preview so the colored source stays intact. Use both a recognition test and an edge test. You want to tell the two symbols apart, and each symbol also needs to be visible against the background it will actually have.

Define the two states in words

Write down what the red and green versions mean. “Ready” and “needs attention” are easier to design for than “green” and “red.” A busy light, a disabled control and an error indicator may need different visual cues even if an earlier design gave them similar colors. Set the meaning before picking the symbol.

Show the existing icons side by side on their normal background. If they are identical circles with different fill colors, a viewer has to identify color to know which state is present. The W3C guidance on using more than color to convey information explains the principle. Build the noncolor distinction into the drawing so it stays visible in a grayscale screenshot or on a display that makes the two colors look similar.

If space permits, use a short label beside the icon. The labels give readers a direct way to learn what the symbols mean. In a tight pixel grid, treat the shape as the primary cue and place the words in a legend or nearby interface when possible. Do not assume everyone will interpret a newly invented symbol in the same way.

Draw two silhouettes and two simple inner marks

On two separate copies of the same target-sized canvas, sketch a rounded silhouette and a pointed one. Keep the icons aligned to the same grid, with similar outer margins. In a 16-by-16 example, a circle can hold a stepped check with a short descending stroke and a longer ascending stroke. The triangle can hold a vertical bar and a separate dot. The outside shape and inner mark now both help identify the state.

Use a deliberate gap between the exclamation mark and the triangle's edge. If the dot is only one pixel and disappears at the intended size, widen it or simplify the outer shape. Keep the check's bend visible when viewed from the ordinary distance. If the two enclosures are too small to support an inner mark, choose larger silhouettes or use a short adjacent text label.

A circle with a check and a triangle with an exclamation remain distinct in grayscale.

Try the outline alone and the inner mark alone. If both versions look like similar blobs, strengthen the shape distinction before choosing brighter red or green. At the final size, a few pixels spent on the silhouette can communicate more than an extra border or an elaborate highlight.

Keep a small working strip of alternatives at the native scale. For example, compare a narrow triangle with a wider triangle, both with the same mark. In a tiny grid, a wider base can make the outline easier to recognize even if the tip becomes less sharp. Then compare two different thicknesses for the check. The aim is to keep its bend and direction readable, especially near the enclosure. Change one part at a time and keep a copy of the previous version beside it.

Compare the icons in grayscale and against their backgrounds

Make grayscale copies from the same two colored exports. The Aseprite color mode documentation describes its RGB, indexed and grayscale modes. Keep the originals in your working color mode and do the conversion on a copy. Grayscale gives you a useful test without color, while other color-vision and display conditions can affect the colors differently.

Compare both states on each background they will use. Start at normal size and verify you can distinguish the check from the alert and the circle from the triangle. Then zoom in to locate a weak outline or filled-in opening. A dark outline that works on white might vanish on a navy background. Adjust the adjacent colors, thickness or spacing and test on both backgrounds again.

If the marks are readable on a neutral background but fail when placed over artwork, test a quiet patch of solid background behind them. Keep the same amount of padding for both states. A consistent patch can preserve the gap around the triangle and the check even where the surrounding image changes. If the design must sit directly on the artwork, identify the darkest and lightest backgrounds it will actually encounter and verify both.

W3C describes non-text contrast for meaningful interface and graphic parts on the web. Use it for the relevant web context. On a physical pixel display, also inspect the actual screen at normal distance and brightness. A numerical comparison does not show whether a one-pixel mark becomes difficult to read in the final environment.

Test both exports at the target pixel size

Export both states at their intended pixel dimensions. Preview them side by side and one at a time. The side-by-side view helps you spot weak differences. The one-at-a-time view tells you whether a person can recognize a state without having the other icon beside it. Try asking someone to name the state from the grayscale version, then repeat with the icons in their normal layout.

Keep the two images on the same background and use the same display scale. Test any important dimmer setting or normal viewing distance for the physical display. If an outline collapses only after export, inspect the resized file and refer to the pixel art export checks for palette and scaling. Change one detail at a time so you can tell what restored the distinction.

When someone confuses the states, ask which shape they saw first. If they correctly saw the triangle but could not explain what it meant, the legend or wording needs attention. If they saw a circle in both cases, revisit the silhouettes. Those responses tell you more than a general preference for one icon.

Check both icons on the physical pixel grid

Pick a repeatable test layout before transferring the art. Use the same margins for both icons and avoid uneven resizing. Show them separately first, then place both on a comparison canvas if the output permits it. Ask whether you can identify the state before walking closer to read a subtle pixel.

The Divoom Pixoo-64 II has a 64-by-64 pixel display. Build an appropriate test image for that grid, using whole-pixel placement and the device's supported transfer process. Check the check mark, triangle and gaps on the actual screen. For a different model in the pixel display collection, verify the grid and format before preparing the comparison.

Écran LED Divoom Pixoo-64Ⅱ WiFi 64x64 Pixel Art & Compteur de médias sociaux Divoom Pixoo-64 WiFi pixel art display with 64x64 LED panel. Social media counter, custom animations, clocks, and community art. App controlled frame. $113.99 USD $149.99 USD avec le code BF26PIXOO64 Buy now

Colored status icons on a monitor and grayscale icons on a lit pixel display.

Save the color originals and the grayscale proof with the same version names. If you later revise the background or icon size, repeat the target-size test with both states.

FAQs About Redesigning Red-and-Green Pixel Status Icons

Can I keep the red and green?

Yes. Keep the colors if they support the design, and use shapes, text or other visible cues that carry the meaning independently.

Is using a lighter green enough?

A lightness difference can help. Use a clear shape or mark as well when the viewer needs to identify the state by itself.

What if I only have an eight-by-eight grid?

Prioritize a single unmistakable silhouette per state. Try a solid check and an alert symbol with generous gaps, then verify both at eight by eight.

Does passing a grayscale test establish accessibility?

It establishes that your test versions work without hue under the conditions you checked. Check relevant contrast, size, labels and the actual display too.

What if the icon works on the computer but not the physical screen?

Verify the exported size and the device grid. Simplify thin strokes and narrow gaps, then inspect both states at normal viewing distance again.

Conclusion

Assign each state its own shape, reinforce it with a simple mark or label, and test both icons in grayscale. Check the colored and grayscale exports at their real size and on the intended background. The redesign works when people can recognize either state without relying on red or green.

Disclaimer: This content is for general information only and is not professional or medical advice, a safety guarantee, or permission to use third-party intellectual property. Follow official product instructions and obtain any required permissions before attempting DIY projects or modifications.

Editor's Recommendation